The First Yes Isn't Always the Right Yes: What I Learned Recruiting Myself
A former D3 basketball recruit and first-generation college student shares why he committed to the wrong school, and how parents can help their kids choose fit first.
Beau4 min read

I was recruited to play college basketball by a handful of D3 schools. I said yes to the first one that offered. A year later, I left. If I could go back and talk to my 17-year-old self, I'd tell him two things: pick the school before the team, and don't do this alone. Now my son plays soccer, and those two lessons are the reason I do what I do.
A 5'7" Guard With No Map
I played basketball. At 5'7", height was never going to be my advantage. I had to be quicker, tougher, and smarter than the guy guarding me.
It worked well enough that a few D3 coaches started reaching out. That should have felt exciting. Mostly, it felt confusing.
My Parents Cared. They Just Didn't Know.
I was one of the first people on either side of my family to go to college. My mom is from Japan. College sports recruiting in America wasn't something she grew up around. Nobody in my family had been through it.
So when coaches reached out, there was nobody at home to ask. What questions should I ask? Is this a good offer? Should I look at more schools? I didn't know. My parents didn't either.
I want to be clear about this. My parents loved me and wanted the best for me. They just didn't have a map. You can't guide someone through a place you've never been.
So I went through it mostly alone. It was a lonely way to make one of the biggest decisions of my life.
I Said Yes to the First School That Said Yes
When the first offer came, I took it. It was a small college in New Hampshire.
Looking back, I know why I jumped. Somebody wanted me. When you're 17 and nobody around you knows how this works, that feels like enough. I was scared that if I waited, the offer would go away.
I never asked myself the important questions. Do I like this campus? Do they have what I want to study? Would I be happy here on a random Tuesday in February when there's no game?
One Year, Then I Left
The school wasn't a good fit for me. It wasn't anyone's fault. It just wasn't the right place.
I stayed one year and transferred. I finished my bachelor's degree somewhere else.
It worked out in the end. But it cost me a year, a lot of stress, and a fresh start I didn't need to make.
School First, Sport Second
Here's what I know now. Playing a sport in college is short. Even if everything goes perfectly, it's four years. Injuries happen. Coaches leave. Playing time changes.
The school is what's left when the sport is over. Your friends, your degree, and the next 40 years start there.
There's a simple test I wish someone had given me. It's called the broken leg test. Ask yourself: "If I got hurt on day one and never played a game, would I still be happy at this school?" If the answer is yes, that's a good sign. If it's no, keep looking.
What I Do Differently With My Son
My son plays soccer. It's a different sport, but the process is the same. Coach emails, ID camps, visits, and offers.
This time, he's not doing it alone. I sit next to him. I don't have every answer. But I ask the questions with him, and we figure it out together.
That's the parent I didn't have growing up. I'm trying to be that for my son, and that's why I built Ninety.
How to Be the Person in the Chair Next to Them
You don't need to be a recruiting expert to help your kid. You just need to be there. Here's where to start:
- Use the broken leg test on every school on the list. Ask it out loud, together.
- Look beyond the team. Check majors, school size, distance from home, and what campus life is really like.
- Don't take the first yes just because it's first. Ask the coach, "When do you need an answer?" A good coach will give you time to decide.
- Know what a D3 offer means. D3 schools don't give athletic scholarships. Any money comes from academic merit or financial aid, so compare what each school will actually cost your family.
- Visit if you can. Sit in on a class. Eat in the dining hall. Stay overnight if they offer it.
- Talk to current players when the coach isn't around. Ask them what they'd change.
- Check how many freshmen come back for a second year. A free government site called College Navigator shows this for every school. If lots of students leave after one year, find out why.
- Keep more than one school on the list. Having options lets you choose fit instead of grabbing the first offer.
You Don't Have to Do This Alone
If you're a parent who never went through recruiting, or never went to college at all, you're not behind. You just need someone with you.
That's what Ninety is for. It gives families the tools to do this themselves: a coach database to find the right programs, an email assistant to reach out from your own inbox, and an ID camp finder. Start with the free Division Fit quiz and find the schools that fit your player first.
Pick the school first. Then go play.


